Best Value vs LPTA
Two fundamentally different approaches to evaluating proposals — and they require different strategies.
Best Value Tradeoff
An evaluation method that considers both technical merit and price, allowing a higher-priced proposal to win if its technical superiority justifies the additional cost.
LPTA (Lowest Price Technically Acceptable)
An evaluation method that awards the contract to the lowest-priced offeror whose proposal meets all minimum technical requirements.
| Dimension | Best Value Tradeoff | LPTA |
|---|---|---|
| Evaluation Approach | Tradeoff between technical merit and price | Pass/fail technical then lowest price wins |
| Technical Scoring | Rated (Outstanding to Unacceptable) with detailed scoring | Binary — Acceptable or Unacceptable only |
| Price Weight | Price is one factor among several; may be less important than technical | Price is the determining factor once technical threshold is met |
| Innovation Rewarded | Yes — exceeding requirements can improve scores | No — exceeding requirements adds cost without benefit |
| Optimal Strategy | Maximize technical scores; justify price with value | Meet every requirement at minimum cost; optimize price aggressively |
| Best Suited For | Complex services, R&D, IT modernization, advisory | Commodities, routine services, well-defined requirements |
Key Takeaway
Best value procurements reward superior technical approaches and allow companies to differentiate on quality, innovation, and experience. LPTA procurements focus purely on price once technical acceptability is established. Your entire proposal strategy must align with the evaluation method — gold-plating an LPTA response wastes money, while underinvesting in a best value technical volume leaves points on the table.
When to Use Each
Best Value
Invest heavily in technical differentiation. Develop strong win themes, demonstrate past performance, and propose innovative approaches. Price to value — don't be the cheapest, be the best justified.
LPTA
Focus on meeting every technical requirement at the minimum acceptable level. Strip out anything that adds cost without improving compliance. Compete aggressively on price — once you're technically acceptable, price is all that matters.
Related Comparisons
Ready to Streamline Your Proposals?
Proposerly automates RFP analysis, compliance tracking, and response generation — so your team can focus on winning.
Get Started Free